Shay's Rebellion: Reading like a Historian (Path to Constitutional Convention) (copy)

You will read the excerpts about Shay's Rebellion & answer the questions

Group 1

In the summer of 1786, farmers in the western counties assembled to petition the Massachusetts legislature for relief. They asked that no taxes be collected for a year, that courts be closed so property could not be confiscated, and that a paper currency be issued to cause inflation, raising the price of farmers’ goods. Citizens from whom these farmers had borrowed money insisted, however, that contracts be honored. Critics called the farmers traitors and agents of the British, even though many were veterans of the Revolution. Some lenders, eager for the money farmers had promised to repay, insisted that debtors should be more industrious and live more frugally. Neither side provided an easy way to resolve the crisis.

Leaders of the farmers’ movement called on the people to be Minutemen, ready at a moment’s notice to defend their liberty as they had during the war. They met in taverns, churches, and town meetings to plot their strategy. Beginning in late August, they armed themselves and converged on county courts, hoping to close them. They reasoned that if the courts could not meet, they could not lose their property.

At the end of August, fifteen hundred angry farmers took up arms and seized the Northampton courthouse. On September 5, the judges tried to convene their court in Worcester, but three hundred bayonet-wielding farmers blocked their access. Over the next month, the rebels shut down courts in Worcester, Middlesex, Plymouth, and Berkshire Counties. In late September, a crowd of fifteen hundred led by Revolutionary War captain Daniel Shays prevented the Massachusetts Supreme Court from meeting in Springfield. Where authorities called out the militia, its members were locals who either refused to muster against their neighbors and kinfolk or who joined them.

“If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary. In framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself.”

Excerpt from Federalist No. 51, James Madison, Feb. 6, 1788

“I hold it, that a little rebellion, now and then, is a good thing, and as necessary in the political world as storms are in the physical… It is a medicine necessary for the sound health of government.” Thomas Jefferson, in a letter to James Madison, Jan., 1787* “The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time, with the blood of patriots and tyrants. It is its natural manure.” Thomas Jefferson, in a letter to Wm. Stephens Smith, Nov., 1787

Thomas Jefferson’s Comments on Shays’s Rebellion

"If three years ago any person had told me that at this day, I should see such a formidable rebellion against the laws & constitutions of our own making as now appears I should have thought him a bedlamite - a fit subject for a mad house." He wrote that if the government "shrinks, or is unable to enforce its laws . . . anarchy & confusion must prevail."

Washington's letter discusses Shays’ Rebellion and the upcoming Constitutional Convention, 1787

Question 1a

Short answer

What does James Madison mean when he says, "you must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself"?

How does this idea relate to the system of checks and balances in the U.S. Constitution?

Question 1b

Short answer

What does Thomas Jefferson suggest about the role of rebellion in a healthy government?

Do you agree or disagree with his perspective? Explain your reasoning.

Question 1c

Short answer

How does George Washington’s reaction to the rebellion reflect his views on government authority and stability?

How does his perspective compare to Thomas Jefferson’s views on rebellion?

Group 2

Question 2a

Short answer

Why was the national government’s inability to collect taxes under the Articles of Confederation a problem?

& How did the lack of an executive branch weaken the government’s ability to function?

Question 2b

Short answer

What were the main concerns of larger and smaller states regarding representation in Congress?

Question 2c

Short answer

In what ways did the Three-Fifths Compromise resolve disputes over taxation and representation between the Northern and Southern states?

Teach with AI superpowers

Why teachers love Class Companion

Import assignments to get started in no time.

Create your own rubric to customize the AI feedback to your liking.

Overrule the AI feedback if a student disputes.