Skip to main content

Real vs. Fake Christmas Trees: Opinion Writing (Perf. Task)

This assignment explores the pros and cons of real and fake Christmas trees. You will read an article comparing both types, answer comprehension questions, and write a 5-paragraph opinion essay using evidence from the article.

Group 1

Read the article above about real and fake Christmas trees. Use the information to answer the comprehension questions below.

Source 1.1

Real vs. Fake Christmas Trees When the holiday season arrives, many families enjoy decorating a Christmas tree. Before the lights and ornaments go up, families have to make an important choice: Should they use a real Christmas tree or a fake one? Both types of trees can make a home feel festive, but each one has its own benefits and challenges. Learning about each type can help you decide which tree might be best for your family.

Real Christmas Trees Real Christmas trees are grown on tree farms for several years before being sold. Farmers take care of the trees by watering them, trimming them, and keeping them healthy. Many families enjoy the tradition of choosing a tree together. Some people say this tradition helps create special holiday memories. A real tree also has a fresh pine smell that many people love. This natural scent can make a home feel warm and cozy.

Even though real trees can be beautiful, they need a lot of care. Real trees must be watered every day so they do not dry out. If they dry out, they may drop many pine needles, and families have to clean them up. Real trees can also be more expensive because you must buy a new one every year. After the holidays, real trees must be recycled, composted, or thrown away.

Fake Christmas Trees Fake Christmas trees are made from materials like plastic, metal, and sometimes nylon. They can be used again and again, which means families do not need to buy a new tree every year. Many fake trees look very real, and some even come with lights already attached. This can make decorating faster and easier.

Fake trees don’t need water, and they don’t shed needles. They are also less likely to cause allergies because they do not carry outdoor pollen or mold. However, fake trees do not have the natural scent of a real tree. Some fake trees can also be large and difficult to store for the rest of the year. Even though they last a long time, fake trees are not easy to recycle when people finally get rid of them. This means they may create more landfill waste.

Whether you choose a real or fake tree, both can help make the holidays special. Families pick the tree that best fits their needs, traditions, and home.

Real vs. Fake Christmas Trees (article provided in assignment)

Question 1a

Short answer

What is one advantage of having a real Christmas tree?

Question 1b

Short answer

What is one disadvantage of a real Christmas tree?

Question 1c

Short answer

How is a fake Christmas tree different from a real one?

Question 1d

Short answer

What are two benefits of using a fake Christmas tree?

Question 1e

Short answer

Which type of tree do you think is better and why?

Group 2

Directions for Writing a 5-Paragraph Opinion Essay: Follow these steps to write a complete opinion essay:

Paragraph 1: Introduction

  • Introduce the topic: real vs. fake Christmas trees.
  • Clearly state your opinion.
  • Use a strong opening sentence to get the reader’s attention.

Paragraph 2: Reason #1

  • Give your first reason why your choice is better.
  • Add details or examples from the article.
  • Explain why this reason supports your opinion.

Paragraph 3: Reason #2

  • Give a second reason and detail.
  • Include facts, examples, or explanations.

Paragraph 4: Reason #3 (optional)

  • Provide a third reason.
  • Support it with details or examples.

Paragraph 5: Conclusion

  • Restate your opinion in a new way.
  • Summarize your reasons.
  • End with a strong closing sentence.

Use linking words such as: for example, also, another reason, in addition, for instance, finally, and in conclusion to connect your ideas.

Question 2a

Essay

Write a 5-paragraph opinion essay about whether real or fake Christmas trees are better. Use the graphic organizer below to plan your essay:

  • My Opinion:
  • Reason 1 + Details:
  • Reason 2 + Details:
  • Reason 3 + Details:
  • Conclusion:

Teach with AI superpowers

Why teachers love Class Companion

Import assignments to get started in no time.

Create your own rubric to customize the AI feedback to your liking.

Overrule the AI feedback if a student disputes.

Other Writing Assignments

주장하는 글을 읽고 주장과 근거 찾기1) Maidu Homes 1 Mastery Connect Benchmark - ELA2) Maidu Food2nd - Benchmark (2nd) Stoplight Paragraph Writing Assignment3.17 Writing Assignment: St. Patricks Day3.18 Writing Assignment3.25 Assignment: The Ultimate Teacher Swap3.30 Bell Ringer3) Maidu Family3rd Grade Bedtime Opinion Piece3rd Grade Bedtime Opinion Piece (copy)4.1 Writing: Artist's Statement4.20 Bell Ringer: Weekend Rating#4 CC Hitchcock and society in the 1950s'4) Maidu Myths4th Grade: On-Demand Writing: Opinion: Spring 2026 BCPS (copy)5) Maidu Clothing5th Grade Informational Essay (District)5th Grade Memory Essay: Reflecting on an Unforgettable Year5th Grade: On-Demand Writing: Opinion: Spring 2026 BCPS6) Maidu Society & CommunityAll About Fossils: Writing AssignmentAnalyzing and Responding to "Shitty First Drafts" by Anne LamottAnalyzing James Baldwin's Letter to His Nephew: A Three-Paragraph ReflectionAnalyzing Purpose, Tone, and Audience in Stephen King's "What Writing Is"Analyzing the Concept of "Wife" in the ArticleAnalyzing 'The Flying Tortoise'Animal Communication AdventureAnimal Superheroes: Surviving Harsh EnvironmentsA Place That Holds a Memory - Personal Narrative AssignmentApology Letter AssignmentApology Letter Assignment Argumentative ECR (copy)Argumentative EssayArgumentative EssayArgumentative Essay: Should We Have a Field Trip to SeaWorld?Argumentative Essay: Taking a Stand (copy)Benchmark #3 - ArgumentBenchmark REDOBiography Writing AssignmentCalifornia Missions Multiparagraph EssayCauses and Effects Leading to the Revolutionary War EssayCEA #1: Issues in Education CEA #2: Ai in Ed Colonial Perspectives: Loyalist or PatriotCompare and Contrast "Creating the Constitution" and "Voting Rights Act Address"Comparing "Hatchet" and "A Cry in the Wild"Creative Story: Narrative Writing Assignment