DBQ: WWI Changed Relationships Between Europeans and Colonized Peoples

Question 1

Essay
In your response, you will be assessed on the following: Respond to the prompt with a historically defensible thesis or claim that establishes a line of reasoning. Describe a broader historical context relevant to the prompt. Support an argument in response to the prompt using at least four documents. Use at least one additional piece of specific historical evidence (beyond that found in the documents) relevant to an argument about the prompt. For at least two documents, explain how or why the document’s point of view, purpose, historical situation, and/or audience is relevant to an argument. Demonstrate a complex understanding of a historical development related to the prompt through sophisticated argumentation and/or effective use of evidence.

Evaluate the extent to which the experience of the First World War changed relationships between Europeans and colonized peoples.
We have been invited to shed our innocent blood in this world war which is now in progress. In the past, it was said indirectly that Africa had nothing to do with the civilized world. But now we find that the poor African has already been plunged into the great war. The masses of our people are ready to put on uniforms, ignorant of what they have to face or why they have to face it. We natives have been loyal since the commencement of this [British] Government, and in all departments of Nyasaland the welfare of the British would have been incomplete without our loyalty. But in time of peace the Government failed to help the underdog. In time of peace everything was for Europeans only. But in time of war it has been found that we are needed to share hardships and shed our blood in equality. The poor Africans who have nothing to win in this present world are invited to die for a cause which is not theirs.

*The letter was published but later retracted by the newspaper’s British editors, and the entire issue was subsequently withdrawn from circulation and destroyed by the Nyasaland colonial government.

Source: John Chilembwe, native of British Nyasaland (present-day Malawi) and ordained Baptist minister, letter sent to the Nyasaland Times,* November 1914.
England is the educator. The patriotism that the English have taught us, the patriotism that all civilized nations have celebrated—that patriotism is responsible for all this bloodshed. We see now that all that patriotism means is snatching away another man’s country. To show patriotism, nationalism, by killing thousands and thousands of people all to snatch away a bit of land, well it’s the English who have taught us this.

The youths of our country, seeing this, have started to practice this brutal form of nationalism. Therefore, killing a number of people, throwing bombs—they have started doing these horrific things. Shame on patriotism. As long as this narrow-mindedness continues, bloodshed in the name of patriotism will not cease. Whether a man throws a bomb from the roof-top or whether fifty men, under orders from their officer, start firing from a cannon-gun at the front line—the cause of this bloodshed, this madness, is the same.
Source: Kalyan Mukerji, Indian officer in the British Indian army that was fighting against the Ottoman army in Iraq, letter to a friend in India, October 1915. The letter was intercepted by British mail censors and was not delivered.
Source: French postcard, showing colonial troops in France and French civilians, 1915. The text of the card says: “Our Black troops in the Great War 1914–1915 [say]: ‘What are we doing here?! . . . We came to kill savages*(*a reference to the fact that German wartime propaganda often depicted colonial troops in the French and British armies as savages). . . the German ones!’”Keystone-France / Contributor
There is no likelihood of our getting rest during the winter. I am sure German prisoners would not be worse off in any way than we are. I had to go three nights without sleep, as I was on a truck, and the Europeans on the truck did not like to sleep next to me because I am an Indian. I am sorry the hatred between Europeans and Indians is increasing instead of decreasing, and I am sure the fault is not with the Indians. I am sorry to write this, which is not a hundredth part of what is in mind, but this increasing hatred and continued ill-treatment has compelled me to give you a hint.
Source: Behari Lal, Indian soldier in the British Indian army on the Western Front, letter to his family, November 1917. The letter was intercepted by British mail censors and was not delivered.
          Laborers and soldiers were forced to travel, leaving their land
          They headed to the battlefields and the trenches!
5
          And now the British blame us for revolting?
          Behold the calamities you have caused! Had it not been for our laborers,
          You and your troops would have been helpless in the desert sand!
10
          Oh, you who are in authority, why didn’t you go all alone to the Dardanelles?*
          Oh Maxwell** now you feel the hardships, how does it feel?
15
          The Egyptian is resilient; and now he is willing and able and can do anything.
          His achievements are worthy of praise, and he will do his all to gain a constitution.
          We are the sons of Pharaohs, which no one can dispute. . . .
20
*The Dardanelles, a narrow strait of water in northwest Turkey, was the site of the famous 1915–1916 Gallipoli campaign. During the campaign, Allied forces attacked the Ottoman Empire and were defeated.
**British commander in Egypt in 1915
Source: Popular Egyptian protest song sung during the Egyptian revolt of 1919 against the British occupation of Egypt. The revolt led to Great Britain’s recognition of Egypt’s nominal independence in 1922.
It has taken 17 years of countless petitions, marching through the streets of Kingston,* as well as agitations before we were given worthless lands in some of the most remote parts of the island without even a well-needed five-pound bill to assist us in making a shabby shelter, much less in trying to cultivate the place for an existence. In some cases, not even wild birds would care to inhabit the worthless lands that we were given. Not even an inch is suitable for cultivation, and as far as roads are concerned, the inaccessibility of the places renders that impossible.

*the Jamaican capital
Source: Hubert Reid, Jamaican veteran of a West Indian regiment in the British Army and leader of a labor union formed to defend the rights of Jamaican war veterans, petition to the British colonial government, 1935.
My experience in the war gave me many lasting things. I demonstrated my dignity and courage, and I won the respect of my people and the [French colonial] government. In the years immediately after the war, whenever the people of my village had something to contest with the French—and they didn’t dare do it themselves because they were afraid—I would go and take care of it for them. And many times when people had problems with the government, I would go with my war decorations and arrange the situation for them. Because whenever the French saw your decorations, they knew that they are dealing with a very important person. So I gained this ability—to obtain justice over the Europeans—from the war.

For example, one day a French military doctor was in our village, and there was a small boy who was blind. The boy was walking, but he couldn’t see and he bumped into the Frenchman. And the Frenchman turned and pushed the boy down on the ground. And when I saw this, I came and said to the Frenchman: “Why did you push the boy? Can’t you see that he is blind?” And he looked at me and said: “Oh, pardon, pardon. I did not know. I will never do it again, excuse me!” But before the war, it would not have been possible for me to interact like that with a European, no matter what he had done.
Source: Nar Diouf, African veteran of a West African regiment in the French army, interview for an oral history project, 1982.

Teach with AI superpowers

Why teachers love Class Companion

Import assignments to get started in no time.

Create your own rubric to customize the AI feedback to your liking.

Overrule the AI feedback if a student disputes.

Other World History Assignments

07.16 The Rwandan Genocide of 1994: An Analysis of Prevention10-26-231.0 The Fall of Rome: Analyzing Contributing Factors11/13/23 - SAQ Reflection11.1 The Great War Begins11.2 A New King of War11/3/23 - Compare Empires and popular religions 1450 to 1750 - Practice LEQ11.3 Winning the War11.4 Making of Peace11.5 Revolution and the Civil War in Russia1.2 & 1.5 SAQ12.2 Nationalism in Africa and the Middle East12.3 India Seeks Self-Rule12.4 Upheavals in China1.2 Developments in Dar al-Islam1.2 Developments in Dar al-Islam from c. 1200 to c. 145013.1 Postwar Social Changes13.2 The Western Democracies Stumble13.3 Fascism in Italy13.4 The Soviet Union Under Stalin13.5 Hitler and the Rise of Nazi Germany1.3 Origins of Humanity Mastery Check14.1 From Appeasement to War14.2 The Axis Advances14.2 The Axis Advances14.3 The Allies Turn the Tide14.3 The Allies Turn the Tide14.4 Victory in Europe and the Pacific14.5 The End of World War II1.4 Causes of the Neolithic Revolution15.1 Quiz15.1 The Cold War Unfolds - 15.2 The Industrialized Democracies15.3 Communism Spreads in East Asia15.4 War in Southweast Asia15.5 The Cold War Ends1.6 Developments in Europe SAQ1.7: Development of Ancient Afro-Eurasian Societies1.7: Specialized Labor, Social Status, and Gender Roles19th & 20th Century Nation-Building19th Century Imperialism1) B204AP-1 AP WORLD HISTORY1 Eclipse short answer questions (SAQs) w/Stimulus 20th Century Movements LEQ Practice AP World History2.1 SAQ Practice Silk Roads (Make-up only)2.1 Silk Roads2.2.A Reactions to Vedic religion and Brahmanism2.2.B The Mauryan Empire and the spread of Buddhism in India2.2.C The Gupta Empire and the revival of Hinduism in India2.2 Eurasia and the Mongol Empire