Rights and Protest :Apartheid Practice Q 15 Comp/ Contrast

Read Sources O and P about the setting up and development of the Bantustans
Source O
The conclusion arrived at by the Commission is that circumstances demand a speedy, definite and unambiguous decision. The Commission is convinced that the separate development of the European and Bantu communities should be striven for, as the only direction in which racial conflict may possibly be eliminated, and racial harmony possibly be maintained. The only obvious way out of the dilemma lies in sustained development of the Bantu Areas on a large scale. This is the first stage in the process of separate development of European and Bantu.
The Commission is convinced that there is no mid-way between the two poles of ultimate total integration and ultimate separate development of the two groups.
5
Looking at it from the narrower point of a regional development programme, the Commission recommends the development of the Bantu Areas on large scale because it will bring about the following:
More productive utilisation of Bantu labour
Provision of more opportunities for free development of Bantu in the Areas
10
Raising of the standard of living in the Bantu Areas
Preservation, as far as possible, of the cultural assets of the Bantu
Logical implementation of state policy as laid down in 1913 and 1936
Creation of a greater diversity of economic activities for the Bantu in the Areas
Demonstration of the good will on the part of the European population
15
Creation of a basis for the political development of the Bantu
Extract from the 17 volume Tomlinson Report, produced by Professor Tomlinson in 1955 to advise the South African government on how apartheid should work in practice. http://historicalpapers-atom.wits.ac.za/1-62
Source  P
he apartheid regime has tried to enforce strict territorial segregation. The greater part of the country has been declared ‘white’. People are forcibly evicted from their homes where these fall within a zone assigned to another group. Most of those moved have been Africans forced into the 13 per cent of land allocated to them. This area consists of numerous fragments grouped into ten units called ‘Bantustans’, most of which are made up of several bits of land. Every African is assigned to a Bantustan, chiefly on the basis of language. The forced removals and resettlement policy has led to a huge increase in the number of people in the Bantustans.

The Bantustans contain few major mineral deposits compared with the rest of the country and few commercial and industrial centres. They cannot support the populations assigned to them. There are few jobs inside the bantustans for their residents, who are needed to work in the rest of the country, in industry and down the mines. The aim has been to allow the homelands to develop greater self-government. However, the Bantustan authorities, lacking legitimacy and popular support are kept in power by the central government and the voting rights of Africans are limited to the Bantustan structures

At every level of life, black South Africans have resisted white rule. The movement for national liberation has always been led by the Africans, who were deprived of their land and who are affected most adversely by the apartheid system.
Extract from ‘This is Apartheid’, a publication from the International Defence and Aid Fund for Southern Africa, published in 1984

Question 1

Short answer
 Question 15 style Paper 1 Q: Compare and contrast what Sources O and P reveal about the setting up and development of the Bantustans

Teach with AI superpowers

Why teachers love Class Companion

Import assignments to get started in no time.

Create your own rubric to customize the AI feedback to your liking.

Overrule the AI feedback if a student disputes.

Other World History Assignments

07.16 The Rwandan Genocide of 1994: An Analysis of Prevention10-26-231.0 The Fall of Rome: Analyzing Contributing Factors11/13/23 - SAQ Reflection11.1 The Great War Begins11.2 A New King of War11/3/23 - Compare Empires and popular religions 1450 to 1750 - Practice LEQ11.3 Winning the War11.4 Making of Peace11.5 Revolution and the Civil War in Russia1.2 & 1.5 SAQ12.2 Nationalism in Africa and the Middle East12.3 India Seeks Self-Rule12.4 Upheavals in China1.2 Developments in Dar al-Islam1.2 Developments in Dar al-Islam from c. 1200 to c. 145013.1 Postwar Social Changes13.2 The Western Democracies Stumble13.3 Fascism in Italy13.4 The Soviet Union Under Stalin13.5 Hitler and the Rise of Nazi Germany1.3 Origins of Humanity Mastery Check14.1 From Appeasement to War14.2 The Axis Advances14.2 The Axis Advances14.3 The Allies Turn the Tide14.3 The Allies Turn the Tide14.4 Victory in Europe and the Pacific14.5 The End of World War II1.4 Causes of the Neolithic Revolution15.1 Quiz15.1 The Cold War Unfolds - 15.2 The Industrialized Democracies15.3 Communism Spreads in East Asia15.4 War in Southweast Asia15.5 The Cold War Ends1.6 Developments in Europe SAQ1.7: Development of Ancient Afro-Eurasian Societies1.7: Specialized Labor, Social Status, and Gender Roles19th & 20th Century Nation-Building19th Century Imperialism1) B204AP-1 AP WORLD HISTORY1 Eclipse short answer questions (SAQs) w/Stimulus 20th Century Movements LEQ Practice AP World History2.1 SAQ Practice Silk Roads (Make-up only)2.1 Silk Roads2.2.A Reactions to Vedic religion and Brahmanism2.2.B The Mauryan Empire and the spread of Buddhism in India2.2.C The Gupta Empire and the revival of Hinduism in India2.2 Eurasia and the Mongol Empire