Mexican Revolution DBQ

Question 1

Essay
1. Evaluate the extent to which economic factors led to the outbreak of the Mexican Revolution (1910–1920). 
The government is not indifferent to the evils afflicting the working class of the Republic: if their wages are inadequate or if they lack employment, the first one to regret this situation is the president. However, these are private ills that fall largely beyond the government's power to correct. Such is the case, unfortunately, of the problems that afflict the working class that you so honorably represent. 
Given the laws that govern our country, the government cannot restrict the freedom of factory owners to fire or hire workers, nor can it intervene directly in the improvement of basic working conditions. No laws permit this nor do any economic interests oblige the government to dictate salaries, or prices, or working hours. 
In your demands, you invoke the right to work. But this right also implies the obligation to find jobs. It cannot be the government's responsibility to supply workers with jobs, or to compel anyone else to supply them. Labor is subject, by unavoidable natural phenomena, to the law of supply and demand. 
Source: Matías Romero Avendaño, finance minister in the government of President Porfirio Díaz, letter to Mexican factory workers who had gone on strike, 1892.
Source: José Guadalupe Posada, Mexican printmaker famous for his depictions of political events, illustration for a popular news print describing the government's suppression of street protests in Mexico City after a disputed election in which Porfirio Díaz was reelected president, despite allegations of widespread voter fraud, 1892. 
Gentlemen, if we compare the Mexico of today with the Mexico of thirty years ago, the justice and the administrative abilities of our President Porfirio Díaz become apparent (applause). In the Mexico of today peace and tranquility reign supreme through the land, public education has made great progress, sanitary regulations are strictly adhered to, railways have been built, and public safety and the rights of foreigners (as well as of Mexicans) are rigidly safeguarded. The [United States] Department of Commerce and Labor recently praised the leaders of the Mexican Republic who, "realizing the necessity for outside aid in developing the natural resources of their country, have wisely framed such laws as are required to guarantee the commercial, financial, and industrial interests of [American] businesses and have thereby achieved the constant increase of foreign capital invested in Mexico." 
All that I have said is sufficient to demonstrate the flourishing condition of Mexico and that we Mexicans, by placing General Díaz at the head of the administration of our country have, as you say, “the right man, in the right place, at the right time.” (applause) 
Source: José Francisco Godoy, Mexican consul in New York City, toast at a banquet given by the New York Chamber of Commerce in celebration of the good business relationship between Mexico and the United States, The Waldorf Astoria Hotel, New York City, 1908.
Slavery in Mexico! Yes, I found it. I found it first in Yucatan. The climate of northern Yucatan happens to be perfectly adapted to the production of henequen.* Here we find vast henequen plantations extending for miles and miles. The owners of these great plantations are the chief slave-holders of Yucatan and the plantation workers are the slaves. The slaves are 8,000 Yaqui Indians imported from Northern Mexico, 3,000 Chinese and Koreans, and between 100,000 and 125,000 native Mayas, who formerly owned the lands that the henequen planters now own. 
The planters do not call their workers "slaves" especially when speaking to strangers. They do not call their system slavery; they call it enforced service for debt. At first I thought it would not be so bad if the servant had an opportunity of buying back his freedom. But I found that such was not the custom. "You need have no fear in purchasing this plantation," one owner said to me, "of the laborers being able to buy their freedom and leave you. They can never do that." "It is very easy to recruit workers," another planter told me. "All that is necessary is that you get some free laborer in debt to you, and then you have him. We are always getting new laborers in that way." 
*a plant that produces tough fibers that were in great demand in the United States and Europe, mostly for use in agricultural harvesting and baling machines 
Source: John Kenneth Turner, United States journalist who had lived in Mexico during the last years of the Porfirio Díaz regime, Barbarous Mexico, travelogue published in Chicago, 1910.
Source: Marion Letcher, United States consul in Chihuahua, Northern Mexico, "United States, British, French, and Mexican Investment in Mexico," report commissioned by the United States Senate subcommittee on Mexico, 1911. The figures are in millions of dollars. 
The right of property is an absurd right because it had its origins in crime, fraud, and abuse of power. In the past, land was worked in common, forests provided firewood to the hearths of all, harvests were distributed among the members of the community according to their needs. In Mexico, this custom thrived in indigenous communities in the era of Spanish domination and existed until recently. The attempt to take away the common lands of indigenous communities caused the recent Yaqui Wars in Sonora and the troubles with the Mayas in the Yucatan. 
The return of the land to the peasants should be accomplished during the present uprising. We revolutionaries will not be committing a crime by turning over the land to the working people, because, by natural law, it already belongs to them. It is the land that their ancestors watered with their sweat; the land that the Spaniards robbed by force from our Indian fathers. That land belongs to all Mexicans. Some of those who own the land currently might have bought it; others might have acquired the land by taking advantage of their friendship with corrupt government officials. Others still acquired the land by giving loans with high interest to the small indigenous farmers, forcing them to leave the land because they could not repay the debt. 
Source: Ricardo Flores Magón, Mexican intellectual and social reform activist of Native American ethnicity, "The Right of Property,” editorial published in the revolutionary newspaper Regeneración (Rebirth), March, 1911.
Listen, dear sirs, to the corrido relating a sad event; 
For Zapata, the great insurgent has been killed. 
The good Emiliano who loved the poor and wanted to give them freedom; 
for this the Indians of the villages joined him in his fight. 
5
Zapata was born among the poor, lived among the poor, and fought for the poor. 
"I don't want riches, I don't want honors," he said to all. 
Mister Zapata, terror of the gachupines** has died! 
Where is our leader Zapata who was the punishment of the rich? 
He said to his followers: "When I am dead, fight to defend your communal lands, like a man should!” He said to his loyal assistant: "As long as I am alive, the Indians will be the owners of their land." 
10
Little stream, what did the flowers tell you? 
"They said that Zapata is not dead, and that he will return.” 
*During the Revolution, corridos were popular songs on current social or political issues, whose lyrics were printed in pamphlet form and either sold or distributed for free by politicians or interest groups. 
15
**a derogatory term for Mexicans of European ancestry 
Source: Anonymous author, "The Death of Emiliano Zapata," a corrido* folk song lyrics, 1919.

Teach with AI superpowers

Why teachers love Class Companion

Import assignments to get started in no time.

Create your own rubric to customize the AI feedback to your liking.

Overrule the AI feedback if a student disputes.

Other World History Assignments

07.16 The Rwandan Genocide of 1994: An Analysis of Prevention10-26-231.0 The Fall of Rome: Analyzing Contributing Factors11/13/23 - SAQ Reflection11.1 The Great War Begins11.2 A New King of War11/3/23 - Compare Empires and popular religions 1450 to 1750 - Practice LEQ11.3 Winning the War11.4 Making of Peace11.5 Revolution and the Civil War in Russia1.2 & 1.5 SAQ12.2 Nationalism in Africa and the Middle East12.3 India Seeks Self-Rule12.4 Upheavals in China1.2 Developments in Dar al-Islam1.2 Developments in Dar al-Islam from c. 1200 to c. 145013.1 Postwar Social Changes13.2 The Western Democracies Stumble13.3 Fascism in Italy13.4 The Soviet Union Under Stalin13.5 Hitler and the Rise of Nazi Germany1.3 Origins of Humanity Mastery Check14.1 From Appeasement to War14.2 The Axis Advances14.2 The Axis Advances14.3 The Allies Turn the Tide14.3 The Allies Turn the Tide14.4 Victory in Europe and the Pacific14.5 The End of World War II1.4 Causes of the Neolithic Revolution15.1 Quiz15.1 The Cold War Unfolds - 15.2 The Industrialized Democracies15.3 Communism Spreads in East Asia15.4 War in Southweast Asia15.5 The Cold War Ends1.6 Developments in Europe SAQ1.7: Development of Ancient Afro-Eurasian Societies1.7: Specialized Labor, Social Status, and Gender Roles19th & 20th Century Nation-Building19th Century Imperialism1) B204AP-1 AP WORLD HISTORY1 Eclipse short answer questions (SAQs) w/Stimulus 20th Century Movements LEQ Practice AP World History2.1 SAQ Practice Silk Roads (Make-up only)2.1 Silk Roads2.2.A Reactions to Vedic religion and Brahmanism2.2.B The Mauryan Empire and the spread of Buddhism in India2.2.C The Gupta Empire and the revival of Hinduism in India2.2 Eurasia and the Mongol Empire