CAASPP Success - Grade 7 Reading Comprehension - Argumentative #2

Is Being an Astronaut a Good Career?

[1] The idea of becoming an astronaut has captured imaginations for decades. Soaring into space, navigating the unknown, and maybe even walking on the moon—these dreams seem straight out of a science fiction novel. But is being an astronaut really a good career choice? The answer isn’t black and white. While this path offers incredible opportunities, it also demands major sacrifices and challenges that can’t be ignored.

5

[2] One of the most compelling reasons to become an astronaut is the unparalleled opportunity to explore space. Few careers give you the chance to be part of missions that push the boundaries of what humanity knows. Astronauts play a crucial role in conducting experiments that can only be done in microgravity—experiments that lead to breakthroughs in medicine, technology, and our understanding of the universe. For those passionate about science and discovery, the rewards of such a career are profound. Many astronauts have spoken about how contributing to humanity’s knowledge of space makes every challenge and obstacle worth it.

[3] However, the journey to becoming an astronaut is far from easy. It’s a path that requires an exceptional level of education—typically in fields like engineering, physics, or biology. Most astronauts hold advanced degrees, and many come from backgrounds as pilots or military personnel. NASA’s astronaut selection process is notoriously competitive, with only a tiny fraction of applicants making the cut. And the challenges don’t stop once you’re selected. Astronauts undergo intense physical and psychological training to prepare for the extreme conditions of space travel. The pressure is immense, and only those fully committed to this demanding path can succeed.

[4] Beyond the academic and physical challenges, the risks of being an astronaut are significant. Space travel is inherently dangerous. From launch to landing, astronauts face potential equipment failures, exposure to harmful radiation, and the physical toll of living in space for extended periods. The tragedies of the Challenger and Columbia disasters serve as somber reminders of how perilous this profession can be. Moreover, the effects of space travel on the human body—such as muscle atrophy, bone density loss, and increased radiation exposure—pose serious long-term health risks. For those who prioritize safety and stability, these risks might outweigh the rewards of space exploration.

10

[5] Despite the challenges, the rewards of being an astronaut can be immense, both professionally and personally. Astronauts are admired worldwide and often find opportunities in leadership roles after their space missions, whether in government, academia, or private industry. The experience of being an astronaut opens doors that few other careers can. Beyond the tangible rewards, many astronauts describe their missions as the pinnacle of their lives. They become lifelong advocates for space exploration, driven by the sense of accomplishment that comes from being part of something extraordinary.

[6] However, these rewards come with personal sacrifices. The training and missions require long periods away from loved ones, which can strain relationships and take a toll on personal well-being. The isolation of space, particularly during long missions aboard the International Space Station, can be overwhelming. For those who value a balanced personal life, the demands of an astronaut’s career might be difficult to reconcile with their goals.

15

[7]  Another aspect to consider is the physical toll that space travel takes on the human body. Extended stays in space lead to serious health issues, including muscle atrophy, bone density loss, and exposure to higher levels of radiation. A study by NASA highlighted how astronauts who spend a year or more in space experience significant changes in their bodies, including altered gene expression and changes in vision. These health risks are crucial to weigh against the allure of space travel, particularly for individuals who prioritize long-term health and wellness.

[8] Plus, the financial side of being an astronaut is worth considering. Although astronauts are well-compensated, their salaries might not be as high as some might expect, especially given the education, training, and risks involved. The starting salary for a civilian astronaut is often comparable to that of other federal government employees with similar qualifications. While the job offers unique experiences, those looking for financial security and higher earning potential might find more lucrative careers elsewhere.

[9] Looking to the future, the landscape of space exploration is rapidly changing with the rise of private companies like SpaceX and Blue Origin. These developments are opening new career paths for aspiring astronauts, but they also bring uncertainties. Unlike traditional government space agencies, private companies often prioritize goals like space tourism or commercial ventures over scientific discovery. While this shift offers exciting new opportunities, it might not appeal to those who dream of purely scientific missions in space.

However, the journey to becoming an astronaut is far from easy. It’s a path that requires an exceptional level of education—typically in fields like engineering, physics, or biology. Most astronauts hold advanced degrees, and many come from backgrounds as pilots or military personnel. NASA’s astronaut selection process is notoriously competitive, with only a tiny fraction of applicants making the cut. And the challenges don’t stop once you’re selected. Astronauts undergo intense physical and psychological training to prepare for the extreme conditions of space travel. The pressure is immense, and only those fully committed to this demanding path can succeed.