7.10 The New Deal - Two Historians

Using the excerpts below and your knowledge of American history, answer parts (A), (B), and (C).
“In eight years, [Franklin] Roosevelt and the New Dealers had almost revolutionized the agenda of American politics. . . Franklin Roosevelt re-created the modern Presidency. . . The White House became the focus of all government — the fountainhead of ideas, the initiator of action, the representative of the national interest. . . For the first time for many Americans, the federal government became an institution that was directly experienced. More than state and local governments, it became the government, an agency directly concerned with their welfare.”
William E. Leuchtenburg, historian, Franklin D. Roosevelt and the New Deal, 1932-1940, published in 1963
“For all the alterations in politics, government, and the economy, the New Deal fell far short of a revolution. The two-party system survived intact, and neither fascism. . . nor communism attracted much of a following in the United States. . . The economy remained capitalistic; free enterprise and private ownership, not socialism, emerged from the 1930s. . . Roosevelt advocated measured change to offset drastic alterations. . . The New Deal’s great achievement was the application of just enough change to preserve the American political economy.”
Roger Biles, historian, A New Deal for the American People, 1991

Question 1

Short answer
Briefly describe one major difference between Leuchtenburg’s and Biles’ historical interpretations of the New Deal.

Question 2

Short answer
Briefly explain how one specific historical event, development, or circumstance from 1932 to 1940 that is not explicitly mentioned in the excerpts could be used to support Leuchtenburg’s argument.

Question 3

Short answer
Briefly explain how one specific historical event, development, or circumstance from 1932 to 1940 that is not explicitly mentioned in the excerpts could be used to support Biles’ argument.

Teach with AI superpowers

Why teachers love Class Companion

Import assignments to get started in no time.

Create your own rubric to customize the AI feedback to your liking.

Overrule the AI feedback if a student disputes.

Other U.S. History Assignments

10/4: Foreign Policy in the Early Republic10/4: Foreign Policy in the Early Republic10/4: Foreign Policy in the Early Republic10/4: Foreign Policy in the Early Republic11.1 Colonial Foundations11.1 Colonial Foundations11.2c: From the Articles of Confederation to the Constitution11.2 CONSTITUTIONAL FOUNDATIONS (1763 – 1824)11.2d: U.S. Government Foundations: Key Developments and Precedents11.2 Reliability - Declaration of Independence11.3 Reliability - Monroe Doctrine1.2 Compare Native Americans in Two Regions1.2 Compare Native Americans in Two Regions1.3 & 1.4 Extent Transatlantic Voyages affected the Americas1 - 4.6 (a) Market Revolution: Society and Culture1 - 4.6 (b) Market Revolution: Society and Culture1 - 4.8 (a) Jackson and Federal Power1 - 4.8 (b) Jackson and Federal Power1 - 4.8 (c) Jackson and Federal Power1492-1700 Interactions with Native Americans1.4 Extent the Columbian Exchange fostered Change(1.4) SAQ - THE COLUMBIAN EXCHANGE14th & 15th Amendments 1865-18771.6 Change because of Interactions Between Europeans & Native Americans1920s: Cultural and Political Controversies1920s Cultural Developments1920s DBQ1920s SAQ1945-Present Unit Exam Reassessment1950s conformity19th Century Immigration and Economic Growth in the United States19th Century Industrialists: Captains of Industry or Robber Barons1 Doc DBQ Antebellum Women1 Doc DBQ Antebellum Women2000 DBQ: Organized Labor's Success in Improving Workers' Position (1875-1900)2018 DBQ Role of US in the World 1865-19102018 Practice Exam - Q1: Historians on the Civil War2018 Practice Exam - Q2: Tire Advertisement - explain2018 Practice Exam - Q3: Compare First Great Awakening to Enlightenment2018 Practice Exam - Q4: Compare Korean War to Vietnam War2018 Practice Exam - Q5: Extent of Change in U.S. Foreign Policy2019 DBQ2019 International Practice Exam DBQ2019 International Practice Exam LEQ2019 International Practice Exam SAQ2019 International Practice Exam SAQ (Required)2023 LEQ Colonial Societies Revolution2.0 Colonial Dynamics and the Fur Trade2.0 Colonial Grievances and Responses: The Case of Nathaniel Bacon2.0 Comparative Goals in Spanish and English Colonial Expansion