September 11, 2023

SPICE-T: From Columbus to Conceptual Frameworks

SPICE-T: From Columbus to Conceptual Frameworks

In 1492, Columbus sailed the ocean blue. This catchy rhyme has been a staple in classrooms for decades, easily sticking in our minds. Yet, there's a vast difference between memorizing a date and understanding its significance. Training students to recall and regurgitate specific dates, key figures, and significant events without context leads to shallow understanding. While this approach ensured students knew "what" happened, it often didn't delve into "why" it happened or "how" it impacted subsequent events and the present. Thankfully, there has been a shift, and not solely for social studies educators. History is not simply a collection of facts. Students can develop a deeper and more holistic understanding of the past by focusing on trends, patterns, and themes. This approach encourages students to think critically, draw connections between different events, and understand the underlying causes and consequences.

Why This Shift is Beneficial

Critical Thinking: Understanding trends requires students to analyze events, discern patterns, and think about causes and effects. This nurtures critical thinking skills, which are invaluable in all areas of life.

Relevance to the Present: Students can better appreciate how past events have shaped the present by understanding historical trends. It fosters a deeper understanding of current events and the world around them.

Engagement: Delving into history's "why" and "how" can make the subject more engaging and relatable for students. Instead of memorizing facts, they are encouraged to discuss, debate, and form opinions.

Preparation for the Future: In our rapidly changing world, the ability to discern patterns, adapt to new situations, and learn from the past is crucial. A trend-focused approach to history equips students with these skills.

The Power of Conceptual Frameworks

Building on this shift towards understanding trends, conceptual frameworks further enhance the study of history. These frameworks, like SPICE-T, provide students with a structured lens through which they can view and analyze historical events. It offers a consistent approach to dissecting the past, ensuring that students consider all facets of an event or era, from social and political implications to technological advancements. Conceptual frameworks empower students to:

Organize Information: They provide a structured way to categorize and connect historical events, making it easier for students to see the bigger picture.

Deepen Understanding: By analyzing events through the various lenses of a framework, students gain a more comprehensive understanding of history, delving into the nuances and intricacies of each event.

Enhance Retention: A structured approach to history helps students remember and recall information more effectively, as they can associate events with specific categories within the framework.

Promote Consistent Analysis: Regardless of the time period or region being studied, conceptual frameworks ensure that students approach history consistently, leading to more balanced and thorough analyses.

It's one thing to discuss this theoretically, but ultimately we want to know the real-world effectiveness and consider the students' perspective. Here’s what two of mine had to say: 

“SPICE-T helps organize important information, which allows me to understand the material better and perform the historical thinking skills we are asked. For instance, compare and contrast is really important in this class, and SPICE-T organizes the relevant information to make comparing and contrasting different civilizations easier. If the question asks me to compare how women are treated in Song China vs. Dar al-Islam, then I can do so much easier since we learned the information by connecting it to subcategories in SPICE-T.” —Rhiannon
“Because of SPICE-T, I can better categorize the information on specific topics and draw connections between them due to overlapping areas. For instance, when studying the Mongols, I was able to separate the massive amount of information into more digestible chunks. For example, the increased trade increasing demand for luxury goods not only helped the economy but also influenced society because artisans and craftsmen became more valued and increased in number.  Trade can also overlap with culture because ideas get exchanged not just goods. All the information overlaps and organizing it with SPICE-T does make it easier and I can better craft my answers too. —Victor

SPICE-T and the AP Exam

The ability to think critically, analyze deeply, and write effectively for AP World History is paramount. With its rigorous writing section, the AP Exam demands students not simply to recall facts but also to recognize trends and weave them into coherent arguments. This is where the power of conceptual frameworks comes into play. When students consistently use SPICE-T in their studies, they develop a structured way of thinking about history. This structure aids immensely in formulating theses, developing arguments, and providing high-quality supporting evidence.

Breaking Down the 2022 AP Exam Questions with SPICE-T

DBQ Question

Evaluate the extent to which imperialism affected economies in Africa and/or Asia in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.

SPICE-T Application:

This question falls squarely under the "Economic Systems" category of SPICE-T. Students familiar with subcategories like "Material wealth," "Trade and commerce," and "Wealth distribution" would be better equipped to address the economic impacts of imperialism. They could delve into how imperialism led to the extraction of natural resources (Material wealth), the establishment of new trade routes and markets (Trade and commerce), and the redistribution of wealth in colonized regions (Wealth distribution).

2022 SAQ 4

a) Identify one scientific or technological development that contributed to the Green Revolution.

b) Explain one way in which the Green Revolution benefited populations in the developing world.

c) Explain one way in which the Green Revolution affected the environment within the developing world.

SPICE-T Application:

Part (a) aligns with the "Technology and Innovation" category, specifically the "Inventions and innovations" subcategory. For part (b), students could tap into the "Economic Systems" category, discussing how the Green Revolution led to increased agricultural production, thereby benefiting economies. Part (c) corresponds with "Interactions of Humans and Environment," where students could discuss the environmental impacts, such as "Pollution, deforestation, desertification."

2022 LEQ 2

In the period before circa 1500, states in the Americas used a variety of institutions, policies, and practices to consolidate their scope and reach. Develop an argument that evaluates the extent to which one pre-Columbian state in the Americas was successful in consolidating and centralizing its authority during this period.

SPICE-T Application:

This question can be approached using the "Political Systems and Governance" category. Subcategories like "Government and leadership," "Structures and organizations," and "Legal and court systems" can guide students in evaluating the political strategies employed by pre-Columbian states. By understanding these subcategories, students can provide detailed evidence of how specific states centralized their authority.


The AP World History exam demands more than rote memorization. It requires students to think critically and make connections. By consistently using the SPICE-T framework in their studies and recognizing its subcategories, students are better prepared to tackle the writing section of the AP Exam. They can formulate stronger theses, develop coherent arguments, and provide detailed, high-quality evidence. Conceptual frameworks go beyond mere tools for memorization and categorization; they are a strategy for success.

Ryan Bravata

Ryan Bravata currently teaches AP US Government and Politics, AP Comparative Government and Politics, and AP World History and served as the Social Studies Department Head at Dutchtown High in Louisiana. He has been a member of the Instructional Leadership Team and Superintendent’s Teacher Advisory Panel while also sponsoring Griffins Fighting Gender Inequality and Rho Kappa National Social Studies Honors Society. He was awarded District Teacher of the Year in 2019. Over the course of his career, Mr. Bravata has participated in many summer institutes including Gilder Lehrman’s Slave Narratives in American Literature at Yale University, NEH Summer Institute: Borders and Borderlands, and the Constitutional Scholars Institute through the Rendell Center. He currently serves as the Pedagogy Director for the Rendell Center for Civic Education

Recent Articles